PME-NA XXII

Twenty-second Annual Meeting of the International Group for the Psycology of Mathematics Education

Tucson, Arizona October 7-10, 2000

Home | Theme | Events | Goals | Program | Pre-Registration | Proposals | Conference | Travel Info | Membership

Table of contents:


Committee
Conference Theme
Schedule of Events
Goals of PME
Scientific Program
Proposals
 Conference Site
Travel
Arizona Organizers/Advisors
More Info
Membership
For Reviewer
 Registration Form ( pdf format )
Conference Papers

  

Proposal Review Form - Empirical

PME XXIII - Tucson
Please submit this form by March 13, 2000

Proposal ID :
Reviewer ID:
Title:

Proposed Format:

Research Report Discussion Group Short Oral
Poster Session    

I. Evaluation
Please check your rationg along each scale given below (please make sure you check only one box per line).

 
5
4
3
2
1
  
1. Choice of Problem
Significant
Insignificant
2.Relationship to PME Goals
High
Low
3. Theoretical framework
Relevant

Non relevant
4 Mode of inquiry
Appropriate
Inappropriate
5. Execution of study
Compelling
Non existent
6. Rigor of analysis
Excellent
Poor
7. Interpretation
Justified
weak

II. Overall Recommendation (check only one)

Accept Accept with Reservation Reject

You may recommend a submission for an alternative presentation format:
Research Report Short Oral Discussion Group Poster Session

 

III. Comments